Valentine’s Day is more than a holiday; it’s a chance to celebrate love and shared moments, often over a romantic dinner for two. Whether you’re newly smitten or a couple of 43 years like Tammy and me, creating the perfect pairing of wine and food is a language of love all its own. This year, let’s elevate your Valentine’s dinner with a themed menu inspired by playful sommelier twists on classic candy heart sayings.

If the Quotes on Candy Hearts Were Written by a Sommelier… They Would Say…

“Be My Rosé” – Start with Sparkling Rosé

Begin your evening with bubbles to set the mood. A sparkling rosé, like Domaine Carneros Brut Rosé from California or Ruinart Rosé Champagne from France, is vibrant and festive. Pair it with an appetizer of smoked salmon mousse on cucumber rounds or strawberry-goat cheese crostini. The delicate bubbles and crisp acidity cleanse the palate while the fruitiness complements the richness of these bites.

“You’re My Main Squeeze” – Move to Mediterranean Magic

For the main course, travel to the sun-soaked Mediterranean with a Greek-inspired lamb moussaka or Moroccan-spiced roasted chicken. Pair these dishes with a Grenache-Syrah-Mourvèdre (GSM) blend from the Rhône Valley, such as Châteauneuf-du-Pape, or a bold yet elegant Agiorgitiko from Nemea, Greece. These wines’ ripe red fruit and herbal undertones mirror the spices and savory depth of the dishes, creating a harmonious match.

“Let’s Get Saucy” – An Italian Interlude

Valentine’s Day is also the perfect excuse for a nostalgic classic. Tammy and I often indulge in spaghetti and meatballs, a dish that symbolizes love and comfort. A Chianti Classico Riserva, like Castello di Ama or Felsina, is the quintessential pairing. Its bright acidity cuts through the rich tomato sauce, while its earthy, cherry notes complement the meatballs.

“You’re Berry Sweet” – End with Chocolate and Port

Finish your meal with a decadent dessert of dark chocolate lava cake or chocolate-covered strawberries. Pair this indulgence with a vintage Port, such as Taylor Fladgate 20-Year-Old Tawny or a ruby Port like Graham’s Six Grapes. The sweet richness of the wine mirrors the chocolate’s depth, while the red berry notes add a luscious counterpoint.

“Sip Happens” – A Cozy Nightcap

To wind down, linger by the fire with a glass of Armagnac or a bold, aged Rioja Gran Reserva. These wines or spirits invite conversation and quiet reflection—perfect for savoring the evening and your time together. Serve with a small cheese board featuring Manchego and Marcona almonds to enhance the experience.

Tips for Success:

• Set the Mood: Use soft lighting, candles, and romantic music to create an intimate atmosphere. Serve each course slowly to savor the meal and the company.
• Glassware Matters: Use the proper wine glasses to enhance the aromas and flavors of your chosen wines.
• Personalize the Pairings: Tailor the menu to your partner’s favorite dishes or wines for an extra thoughtful touch.

A Little Less Dye… a Little More Wine?

In case you were wondering why your candy hearts are looking a little pale this year, blame the recent ban on Red Dye Number 3 (Erythrosine). That’s right—our beloved neon-pink confections are facing an identity crisis. But don’t worry, while the candy industry scrambles for a replacement, we sommeliers are more than happy to step in with a rosé or ruby port to keep your Valentine’s Day looking (and tasting) just as sweet!

Valentine’s Day is a time to celebrate your love story—and there’s no better way to do that than with an unforgettable wine dinner. Cheers to love, laughter, and perfect pairings! ♥️