On October 28, 2023, an enchanting event unfolded in a private suite at Disney’s Riviera Resort, a night that will be fondly remembered by those lucky enough to attend. It marked the 35th Wedding Anniversary of Scott and Alison White, a couple known for their love of fine wine and fine company. Although their actual anniversary date was October 30th, they thoughtfully planned this special celebration a few days in advance to accommodate their dear friends and family with busy schedules. It turned out to be a decision that would create an unforgettable evening filled with elegance, exceptional wine, and camaraderie.

The centerpiece of the evening was a Chateau Montelena themed 5-course wine dinner featuring five decades of the legendary Cabernet Sauvignon wines of Chateau Montelena: 1978, 1988, 1998, 2008, and 2018. As each guest arrived, they were greeted with a glass of the 2020 Chateau Montelena Chardonnay, a delightful prelude to the remarkable evening that awaited them. The bright and beautifully floral wine flowed as guests mingled, setting the stage for a night of memorable moments.

The uniqueness of this event became apparent when all five different Cabernet Sauvignons were poured at the beginning of the meal. This format allowed every vintage to be compared with all five courses. To enhance the experience and create a lasting memory, special tasting mats were thoughtfully provided for the 32 guests, inviting them to take notes and record their journey through these remarkable wines.

Our ties may not be by blood, but they’re definitely by bottle… and I dare say, that’s even stronger!

Gregory Dean

Adding an extra layer of enchantment to the evening, Chris Grossman, a Certified Specialist of Wine (CSW) from Chateau Montelena, was in attendance as the special guest. His presence was akin to having the gatekeeper of a vinous treasure trove share the secrets and stories behind each bottle. Chris regaled the guests with detailed information about each wine, unveiling the history and the little-known tales of the fabled Chateau Montelena. His insights and storytelling elevated the entire experience, making it all the more special.

As for the culinary side of the evening, the menu was meticulously curated, offering a perfect marriage of flavors with the exceptional wines:

Beets Three Ways: The evening commenced with a dish that celebrated the versatility of beets, prepared three ways and complemented by fine herbs and red wine vinaigrette.

Roasted Butternut Squash Soup: The second course brought to the table a velvety roasted butternut squash soup, adorned with pepitas and pomegranate seeds.

Char-Crusted Swordfish: The third course introduced char-crusted swordfish, accompanied by creamed leeks and a cabernet reduction.

Cabernet-Braised Short Rib: The fourth course featured tender cabernet-braised short ribs, served with red wine-braised onions and polenta.

Reverse-Seared Ribeye: The grand finale was a succulent reverse-seared ribeye, presented with smoked gouda mac & cheese, charred Brussels sprouts, and a tantalizing blackberry sauce.

As the evening progressed, there was no shortage of opinions and expressions of how each wine paired with every dish. In fact, there were eight (8) sommeliers among the thirty-two (32) total guests. This created an atmosphere of wine knowledge euphoria 😉 With the penta-deca-vertical (a Scott White coined phrase) poured, each course was meticulously prepared and served. Here is my summary of how these wines paired with the dishes:

Beets Three Ways – The older, softer wines (1978 and 1988) were my favorite wines for this dish. The 1998 with the golden beets in this dish were definitely a favorite.

The 1978 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon, a wine matured with time, gracefully complemented the “Beets Three Ways.” Its aged elegance showcased a symphony of flavors with subtle hints of blackberries, dried herbs, and a delicate touch of leather. This wine lent a refined depth to the dish. The earthy beets in their various preparations resonated with the wine’s complex character, creating a harmonious balance between sweet and savory, which was a testament to the beauty of well-aged Cabernet Sauvignon.

The 1988 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon, known for its rich dark fruit flavors and velvety texture, engaged in a delightful dance with the “Beets Three Ways.” The wine’s fruity undertones accentuated the natural sweetness of the beets while its tobacco notes offered a contrasting depth. This pairing brought out the best in both wine and dish, creating a symphony of flavors where the earthy and peppery aspects of the beets were beautifully elevated by the wine’s round finish.

Roasted Butternut Squash Soup – This dish was earthy and rustic, so the older vintages seemed to be a natural fit. My favorite, however, was the 1998 with this particular dish.

The 1998 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon, characterized by dark plum, tobacco, and cedar, offered a captivating interplay with the Roasted Butternut Squash Soup. The wine’s firm tannins and depth created a delightful contrast to the soup’s creaminess. The wine’s dark fruit elements harmonized with the soup’s sweetness, while its structural integrity accentuated the dish’s complexity. This pairing celebrated the diverse characteristics of both the wine and the cuisine, creating an engaging and rich experience.

Char-Crusted Swordfish – This dish was diverse enough to work well alongside any of the vintages. At one point I witnessed a guest enjoying this dish with the 2020 Chateau Montelena Chardonnay 😉 It’s this very reason that I leaned into a contrasting pairing as opposed to the classic complementing approach.

The 2008 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon, recognized for its balanced blackberry, cassis, and hints of eucalyptus, offered a refreshing twist to the Char Crust Swordfish. The wine’s depth and the hints of eucalyptus provided a unique contrast to the dish. The wine’s dark fruit flavors harmonized with the swordfish’s flavors, while its structural integrity accentuated the overall complexity of the dish. This pairing showcased the wine’s ability to provide a dynamic and revitalizing counterpoint to seafood.

Cabernet-Braised Short Rib – This savory dish required a wine with pronounced fruit, body, and bolder tannins. The 2018 was a perfect fit!

The 2018 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon, the most recent vintage, unveiled bold blackberry, currant, and dark chocolate notes, creating an opulent and luxurious pairing with the Cabernet-braised Short Rib. The wine’s dark fruit and chocolate undertones beautifully complemented the richness of the short rib, enhancing the overall experience. The red wine-braised onions and polenta found a luxurious partner in this vintage, creating a grand and flavorful conclusion to the dish. This pairing set a decadent tone for the rest of the wine dinner, emphasizing the wine’s versatility and its ability to elevate classic comfort food to new heights.

Reverse-Seared Ribeye – The final dish in the 5-course pairing would have easily stood up to any of the vintages in our penta-deca-vertical. My preference, however, was the 1978 vintage.

The 1978 Chateau Montelena Cabernet Sauvignon, with its well-aged complexity, presented a captivating contrast to the Reverse-seared Ribeye. This vintage’s notes of blackberries, dried herbs, and subtle leather added depth and sophistication to the rich, succulent ribeye. The wine’s smooth tannins and long finish created an elegant harmony with the dish, bringing out the ribeye’s bold flavors and creating a luxurious and timeless pairing.

Just when the evening couldn’t possibly get better… dessert was served! It was a melody of sweet classics–including creme brûlée (a personal favorite). These dessert dishes were served to enjoy alongside a luscious Chateau Montelena Late Harvest and Chateau Montelena Ruby-style Port (very exclusive).

We could not have scripted a better evening with a better group of friends. Thanks Scott and Alison for the friendship and shared love of food and wine.

…So raise your glasses, give a hearty cheer, To Scott and Alison, who’ve persevered; Through all the years, come what may, Here’s to more laughter, on this special day!

From the 35th Anniversary Toast – Gregory Dean

A few memories captured by Erin Toung. Thanks, Erin, for the wonderful photos 😉